These Hot Dog Joints Are the GOAT

hiram's - hot dog joint

Summer means baseball and hot dogs. But you don’t have to hit your local stadium to get a taste of frankfurter excellence.

These hot dog joints – the greatest of all time (or GOATs) in the sausage world, if you will – have been drawing crowds for decades, and in some cases, more than a century.

Whether you call them wieners, rippers, red hots, franks or dogs, these joints don’t mess with success. Original “secret” recipes are still being served at all of them. How’s that for a home run?

Prefer an audio summary of this post? Click below to listen to this article.

Blackies

Cheshire, Conn., opened in 1928

Fans beeline to this Cheshire hot dog joint for its unique hot pepper relish – a secret family recipe that has made it to the International Space Station! The peppers are picked locally and then bottled fresh and served as a topper for one of Blackie’s naturally cased pork and beef hot dogs, made exclusively for them by a local butcher. Its iconic red building has been maintained by the current generation, as are a few quirks: Blackie’s does not serve french fries – just potato chips – and is closed on Fridays.

Casey’s Diner

Natick, Mass., opened in 1890

Opened in 1890 and now run by the fourth generation of the same family, this classic 10-stool diner is listed on the National Register of Historic Places. The menu is full of diner staples, but diehards come for the natural-cased franks, which are steamed and then served in a bun from Casey’s original 132-year-old copper bun steamer. Have yours “all-around,” which is served with mustard, relish and onions. Add a root beer float and you can’t get any more old-school than that.

Hiram’s Roadstand

Fort Lee, N.J., opened in 1932

The Garden State is known for its rippers – pork and beef hot dogs, deep-fried until they rip open. The late chef and author Anthony Bourdain got his rippers at this bustling spot, popular with locals and adventurous foodies alike, many of whom learned about Hiram’s from an episode of Bourdain’s “Parts Unknown.” The dogs are large and plump, served on a toasted roll and delivered in a cardboard box. Order one well done, topped with cheese or smothered in chili with a side of excellent onion rings and a cold birch beer on tap. Cash only.

Olneyville New York System

Providence and Cranston, R.I., opened in 1946

Rhode Islanders are fierce about their wieners (don’t call them hot dogs or ask for ketchup!). One of the best-known in the state is served at this family-owned spot, named a James Beard American Classic in 2014. Purists order theirs “all the way,” a beef, pork and veal wiener served off the grill in a steamed bun with mustard, onions, celery salt and Olneyville’s signature meat sauce. (You can buy the spice packet and make your own at home.) Wash ‘em down with another Rhode Island mainstay: coffee milk, a blend of coffee syrup and milk.

Walter’s Hot Dog Stand

Mamaroneck, N.Y., opened in 1919

Fans line up in all seasons under the distinctive green pagoda at this nationally recognized 104-year-old hot spot, now run by the fourth generation of the Warrington family. They’re waiting for Walter’s beef, veal and pork dogs, split down the middle and grilled in a secret sauce, then served on a toasted bun. Get it plain or topped with the signature mustard – a blend of mustard seeds, spices and relish. But don’t get just one! Walter’s also sells ready-to-cook hot dogs and mustard on Goldbelly.

Restaurant Recipe Guide

Featuring more than 40 recipes and tips from top chefs and kitchens in the Northeast. Download the Restaurant Recipe Guide and get cooking!

Download Now!

More of the Best Hot Dogs To Try

  • Heid’s of Liverpool – Heid’s has been serving up Hofmann hot dogs in Central New York since 1917 with an array of toppings including relish, chili, and even mushrooms. Bring home a jar of their proprietary Heid’s mustard.
  • Hot Dog Johnny’s – In business since 1948, this iconic roadside stop in Belvidere, N.J., serves up dogs fried in peanut oil that fans pair with a frosty mug of birch beer. Look for the giant hot dog on the roof.
  • Baba’s The Original New York System – It’s a toss-up on who has the better Rhode Island wiener, Olneyville or Baba’s, so let’s just say it’s eater’s choice. Opened in 1927, Baba’s is one of the state’s oldest wiener joints.

Who do you think makes the greatest hot dog of all time? Share your favorite hot dog joints in the comments.

Featured image: Hiram’s Roadstand

SUBSCRIBE TO YOUR AAA NEWSLETTER

Sign up and receive updates for all of the latest articles on automotive, travel, money, lifestyle and so much more!

59 Thoughts on “These Hot Dog Joints Are the GOAT

  1. I thought Jack’s Hot Dogs In North Adams, MA would be included! Now run by Jack’s grandson and great grandson, it has been supplying the area for over 100 years. A great deal for the price! We stop in this little hole in the wall often!

    1. I’m astounded that you didn’t list Rutt’s Hut, which has been serving it’s famous hot dogs in Clifton, N.J. for decades. Every other review about the best hot dog joints that I’ve read always rates them as #1 along with the original Nathan’s. You can Google this. People travel there from all over the east coast. I’m a foodie who lives on Long Island and still make the two hour trip occasionally. The millions of people who’ve eaten there for eons will not appreciate the article. It would be tantamount to generating a list of America’s GOAT skyscrapers, which leaves out The Empire State Building.

  2. CONEY ISLAND Worcester, MA!! Come on, how could you leave this place out. Since 1918. Best in New England!!
    I have been going there over 50 years and I am a rookie!!
    Best Chili dogs by far. Steamed buns. Order the dogs with the works.

  3. Flos on Rt. 1 in southern Maine is incredible. They have been selling since I think for over 75 years. The small eater only sells hot dogs chips and soda. That’s it! If you’re tall, like myself, you won’t even to able to stand up fully inside. A homemade relish (you’ve never had a relish like this) and mayo is what most people order (a must try). It you can also get the traditional mustard, relish, onions as well. Don’t even try to order ketchup. So popular in fact that most days around the lunch hour you have to wait up to 30 minutes to get your dogs or weiners.

Leave A Comment

Comments are subject to moderation and may or may not be published at the editor’s discretion. Only comments that are relevant to the article and add value to the Your AAA community will be considered. Comments may be edited for clarity and length.

YOUR EMAIL ADDRESS WILL NOT BE PUBLISHED. REQUIRED FIELDS ARE MARKED *